Political Forum - US & World Political Discussion Forums - View Single Post - Should health care precede religious belief...

Viv · 11-06-2007, 03:42 PM

This family refused life-saving treatment because of their religious beliefs, resulting in the birth of two healthy babies and the death of their 22-year-old mother.

For me, this is a nonsense and a prime example that religion requires regulation by law, to ensure the rights of the individual are protected in the face of unreasonable outdated fanatacism.

Do posters feel the family were right to stand by their beliefs, or should medical assistance have been given irrespective?

Quote:

| the Daily Mail

A young mother died hours after giving birth to twins because her faith prohibited a life-saving blood transfusion.
Emma Gough, 22, was able to hold her son and daughter after the natural delivery, but suffered a sudden haemorrhage and lost a great deal of blood.
As a Jehovah's Witness, Mrs Gough had signed a form before the birth insisting that she should not be given blood.
Staff at the Royal Shrewsbury Hospital begged her husband Anthony, 24, who is also a Jehovah's Witness, and other relatives to allow the transfusion. But followers believe that blood transfusions are prohibited by the Bible and the family would not sanction the treatment.
Mrs Gough, a shop worker from Dawley, Telford, Shropshire, died early on October 25.
The twins are being cared for by their father, who yesterday led the mourners at his wife's funeral…Mrs Gough's death devastated both sides of the family, all Jehovah's Witnesses…What makes it even more sad is Emma had time to bond with her twins before the complications set in." …Mrs Gough's parents, Glenda and James Delaney, a long- distance lorry driver, were too upset to comment at their Telford home yesterday.
But an elderly neighbour criticised the family for sticking to their beliefs.
She said: "How could she make that decision not to have a transfusion and leave those babies without a mother? It's terrible, I don't care what your beliefs are, to refuse treatment like that is awful."
Another neighbour said: "A friend of the family told us she had suffered a haemorrhage after giving birth to the twins naturally and had refused a transfusion. They couldn't understand why she hadn't been given a Caesarean."
A member of the Kingdom Hall congregation in Madeley, Telford, said: "The basis of the faith is that we follow commands from the scriptures and it is a scriptural command to abstain from blood.
"It is one of a number of things in the scriptures about things you can and cannot do. It is, of course, up to the individual to decide how strongly to follow these requirements. I accept that the faith will receive criticism over this. Some of our beliefs do attract criticism."
He denied that Mrs Gough was being selfish by putting her own beliefs before the needs of her children, adding: "Children are always a priority. We respect life. We seek the best medical attention we can get but the requirement we have is that we do so without receiving blood. It is very sad and there is a lot of support for the family."
Dr Maggie Blott, a consultant obstetrician, said women pregnant with non-identical twins are at increased risk of needing a blood transfusion at birth…Last year only 17 women died in childbirth in Britain.
• The Jehovah's Witness movement, an offshoot of Christianity, was developed by the American preacher Charles Taze Russell in the late 19th century.
Its adherents believe Christ's second coming is imminent, and that soon afterwards the world will be destroyed and 144,000 of the most faithful believers will ascend to heaven.
They consider the Bible to be the word of God - whom they call Jehovah - and interpret many of its scriptures literally.
Witnesses believe three Biblical passages explicitly prevent them from receiving blood transfusions. However the faith's ruling Watchtower Society allows Witnesses to receive organ transplants, as long as the organ is completely drained of blood.
There are 6.5million active Jehovah's Witnesses worldwide, 125,000 of them in Britain. Followers include Michael Jackson and tennis stars Venus and Serena Williams.